F.I.R.E. Institute
Investing·October 31, 2026·7 min read

Target Date Fund or Index Fund: Which One to Buy First

Both are good first funds. Here's what each one holds, what they cost at Schwab, Fidelity and Vanguard, the lookalike that charges several times as much, and how to pick in five minutes.

By Jonathan Seal, Founder, FIRE Institute

Target Date Fund or Index Fund: Which One to Buy First

You've opened a Roth IRA or a brokerage account, and now it's sitting there as cash, waiting for you to buy something. If you're starting out, the choice comes down to two funds: a target date index fund or a total stock market index fund. Both are good answers. The real mistake is spending months deciding and leaving the money in cash while you do.

Here's what each one is, what they cost, and how to pick.

A target date fund: one fund that does everything

A target date fund holds thousands of US and international companies plus bonds, all in one fund. The year in its name is roughly when you'll start using the money. Far from that year, it's mostly stocks so it can grow. As the year gets closer, it moves toward bonds, so a bad year near the end hurts less. That schedule is called the glide path.

At Vanguard, for example, a target date fund holds about 90% stocks until you're roughly 25 years out, about half stocks in its target year, and keeps easing toward bonds for several years after. It rebalances itself along the way, so you never have to.

Which year? The usual pick is the year near when you'll turn 65. If you plan to retire early, you could pick your FI year instead, but that moves you into bonds sooner, and your money has to last longer. If you retire early, the later year can still be the better fit for that reason. The SEC's investor bulletin on target date funds makes the same point: the year in the name is a guide, and a fund a few years earlier or later may suit you better.

A total stock market index fund: the whole US market, for almost nothing

A total stock market index fund owns nearly every public company in the US, thousands of them, in one fund. It has the lowest fees you'll find, from 0.015% to 0.03% a year, or 15 to 30 cents for every $1,000.

The catch is that it's all stocks. It rises more in good years and falls more in bad ones, with no bonds to soften a drop, and it holds no international companies. If you want those later, adding them is up to you.

Side by side

Target date index fundTotal stock market index fund
What it holdsUS and international stocks, plus bondsUS stocks only
Yearly feeAbout 0.08% to 0.12%About 0.015% to 0.03%
RebalancingDoes it for youNothing to rebalance until you add funds
In a bad yearFalls a little less, thanks to the bondsFalls with the market
Work for youNone, now or laterNone now; some later if you add bonds

What they cost at the big three

Here are both kinds at the three biggest do-it-yourself brokerages. The fees and minimums were checked on October 31, 2026; check the fund's own page before you buy.

BrokerageTarget date index fundTotal market index fund
Charles SchwabSchwab Target Index funds (2060: SWYNX), 0.08% a year, no minimumSchwab Total Stock Market Index (SWTSX), 0.03%, no minimum
FidelityFidelity Freedom Index funds (2060: FDKLX), 0.12% a year, no minimumFidelity Total Market Index (FSKAX), 0.015%, no minimum
VanguardVanguard Target Retirement funds (2060: VTTSX), 0.08% a year, $1,000 to startVanguard Total Stock Market ETF (VTI), 0.03%, from $1

At Vanguard, the Target Retirement fund needs $1,000 for the first purchase. Until you have it, your money waits as cash, so if you're starting with a small amount each month, the ETF lets you buy from the first dollar.

Watch for the lookalike

Some fund families have two versions with almost the same name. At Fidelity, Freedom Index 2060 charges 0.12% a year. Freedom 2060, without "Index" in its name, is a different, actively managed fund that charges about 0.7%, around six times as much. Schwab has the same pattern: its Target 2060 Index fund charges 0.08%, and its Target 2060 Fund (SWPRX), without "Index", charges 0.57%, about seven times as much (checked November 14, 2026).

Before you buy, check two things on the fund's page: "Index" in the name, and an expense ratio under 0.20%.

The one you'll stick with matters most

The fund matters less than whether you leave it alone. Morningstar's 2025 Mind the Gap study found that investors earned about 1.2 percentage points a year less than the funds they owned over ten years, mostly from buying and selling at the wrong times. Investors in all-in-one funds like target date funds kept more of their funds' returns than investors in most other kinds of funds.

Target date funds are also what most people end up holding at work. In Vanguard's How America Saves 2026 report, 61% of people in its 401(k) plans were in a single target date fund at the end of 2025, and only 1% of them made a trade during the year.

Three mistakes to skip

  • Holding a target date fund alongside other funds. It's built to be your whole mix. Add other funds and you change that mix without meaning to. If you want more control, a total market fund plus a bond fund is the cleaner way.
  • Buying two target date funds with different years. Two funds doing the same job just muddy the mix. Pick one year.
  • Picking whichever did best last year. Two target date funds with the same year can look different over a short stretch. Over decades, the fee is what you can count on.

So which one?

If you're not sure, pick the target date index fund and move on. It's the one with nothing left to decide. If you want the lowest possible fee and you know you can sit through a 30% drop without selling, pick the total stock market fund. Either way, set it to buy on its own every payday. Here's how to set up automatic investing, and if you haven't opened the account yet, here's how to open a Roth IRA.

General education, not personalized investment advice. Fees and minimums change, so check each fund's page before you buy. None of the links in this post pay us anything.

Put this into action

Sign up free and I’ll send the first lesson of the 30-Day FIRE Kickstart Challenge straight to your inbox, along with new guides and calculators as they land.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.