F.I.R.E. Institute
Investing·October 30, 2026·7 min read

What to Do When the Stock Market Drops

Stocks have fallen hard many times since 1928, and still ended the year up in 72 of 98 years. What history shows, what selling costs, and a plan to make before the next drop.

By Jonathan Seal, Founder, FIRE Institute

What to Do When the Stock Market Drops

The stock market will drop again. Every long-term investor lives through a handful of big falls and dozens of smaller ones, and nobody can tell you when the next one starts. What you can control is what you do while it's happening, and that turns out to matter a lot.

Drops are normal

Here's every year of the S&P 500 since 1928, dividends included. Hover or tap a year to read it.

The S&P 500’s return each year from 1928 to 2025: up in 72 of 98 years.
Up: 72 yearsDown: 26 years

Hover or tap a year to read it

Most years are green. The red ones are what you sit through to get them.

See every year
YearS&P 500
2025+17.8%
2024+24.9%
2023+26.1%
2022−18.0%
2021+28.5%
2020+18.0%
2019+31.2%
2018−4.2%
2017+21.6%
2016+11.8%
2015+1.4%
2014+13.5%
2013+32.1%
2012+15.9%
2011+2.1%
2010+14.8%
2009+25.9%
2008−36.5%
2007+5.5%
2006+15.6%
2005+4.8%
2004+10.7%
2003+28.4%
2002−22.0%
2001−11.8%
2000−9.0%
1999+20.9%
1998+28.3%
1997+33.1%
1996+22.7%
1995+37.2%
1994+1.3%
1993+10.0%
1992+7.5%
1991+30.2%
1990−3.1%
1989+31.5%
1988+16.5%
1987+5.8%
1986+18.5%
1985+31.2%
1984+6.2%
1983+22.3%
1982+20.4%
1981−4.7%
1980+31.7%
1979+18.5%
1978+6.5%
1977−7.0%
1976+23.8%
1975+37.0%
1974−25.9%
1973−14.3%
1972+18.8%
1971+14.2%
1970+3.6%
1969−8.2%
1968+10.8%
1967+23.8%
1966−10.0%
1965+12.4%
1964+16.4%
1963+22.6%
1962−8.8%
1961+26.6%
1960+0.3%
1959+12.1%
1958+43.7%
1957−10.5%
1956+7.4%
1955+32.6%
1954+52.6%
1953−1.2%
1952+18.1%
1951+23.7%
1950+30.8%
1949+18.3%
1948+5.7%
1947+5.2%
1946−8.4%
1945+35.8%
1944+19.0%
1943+25.1%
1942+19.2%
1941−12.8%
1940−10.7%
1939−1.1%
1938+29.3%
1937−35.3%
1936+31.9%
1935+46.7%
1934−1.2%
1933+50.0%
1932−8.6%
1931−43.8%
1930−25.1%
1929−8.3%
1928+43.8%

The S&P 500 each calendar year, with dividends reinvested, 1928 to 2025. Source: Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern.

Of those 98 years, 72 ended up. Down years come about one year in four, and a few have been brutal: stocks lost 43.8% in 1931 and 36.5% in 2008.

Even the good years have scary stretches. J.P. Morgan found that from 1980 to 2023, the S&P 500's average drop within a year, from its high to its low, was about 14%, and the year still ended up in 33 of those 44 years. If you check your balance often, a double-digit drop at some point in the year is normal. That's what owning stocks feels like, even in the years that end well.

The big ones, and how long they took to come back

DropFall from top to bottomBack to the old high
2000 to 2002, the dot-com crashAbout 49%About 4½ years after the bottom
2007 to 2009, the financial crisisAbout 57%About 4 years after the bottom
2020, the pandemicAbout 34%, in five weeksAbout 5 months after the bottom
2022, rising interest ratesAbout 25%About 15 months after the bottom

These use the S&P 500's price alone. Counting dividends, each recovery came a little sooner. In every one of them, people who kept buying on the way down got shares at lower prices, and the recovery paid them first.

What selling costs

Selling after a drop feels like stopping the bleeding. Usually it locks the loss in, and it leaves you a second decision, when to buy back, that almost nobody gets right. The market's best days tend to come soon after its worst ones, before the news has turned. J.P. Morgan has found that over 20 years, missing just the 10 best days cut an investor's yearly return almost in half, and most of those days came within two weeks of the worst ones.

This shows up in real money, too. Morningstar compares what funds earn with what the people in them earn after all their buying and selling. Over the 10 years to 2025, the average dollar in US funds earned 8.7% a year while the funds themselves earned 9.9%. The gap came from timing: money pouring in after rises and leaving after drops.

A 1.2-point gap doesn't sound like much. On $500 a month for 30 years, it's roughly the difference between $1 million and $800,000.

A plan to make before the next drop

The best time to decide what you'll do in a crash is now, while nothing is happening. These make the plan much easier to keep:

  1. Keep your automatic investing on. It keeps buying through the drop, at lower prices, without you having to be brave.
  2. Keep an emergency fund. Three to six months of expenses in savings means a lost job or a big bill never forces you to sell at the bottom.
  3. Only invest money you won't need for five years or more. A house down payment you need next year belongs in savings, not stocks.
  4. Pick a fund you can sit with. A target date fund holds some bonds, so it usually falls a little less, and Morningstar has found that people in all-in-one funds like these lose the least to bad timing.
  5. Look less. Checking your balance every day during a drop makes selling feel urgent. Once a month is plenty.
  6. Write it down. One sentence, somewhere you'll see it: "When the market falls 30%, I will keep investing on schedule."

If a drop comes while you have a full emergency fund and extra cash, putting more in has paid off after every drop in the table above, for anyone who could wait for the recovery. Just make sure it's money you truly won't need for years.

When selling does make sense

There are good reasons to sell investments. You're retiring and need the income. You're rebalancing back to the mix you chose. Or the money was never meant for stocks in the first place. Scary news isn't one of them. If a drop shows you that you can't stomach as much in stocks as you thought, change your mix once things have recovered, not halfway down.

Where this fits

On Day 24 of the 30-Day FIRE Kickstart, you look at every one of these years and pick your plan before you've invested a dollar. If you're not in the Kickstart, you can do the same thing today: write your sentence, and set your investing to run on its own. It also helps to know that a Roth IRA isn't an investment on its own, so make sure your money is actually in a fund.

General education, not personalized investment advice. Past returns don't guarantee future ones, and every number here is a historical illustration.

Put this into action

Sign up free and I’ll send the first lesson of the 30-Day FIRE Kickstart Challenge straight to your inbox, along with new guides and calculators as they land.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.